"Is Virtue Teachable": An Interpretation of Protagoras and Meno
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54097/gy0ckb24Keywords:
Virtue, Moral Education Theory, Moral Education, SocratesAbstract
Whether virtue is teachable or not is a prerequisite question that moral education theories must answer. Throughout the Protagoras and the Meno, Socrates debates on the theme of "Virtue", and Socrates puts forward the proposition of moral education that "Virtue is Knowledge" in the dialogues. Throughout the text, however, Socrates expresses himself differently in different contexts, which leads to a paradox that is essentially a difference in the understanding of "teaching". Unlike the emotional theory of moral education held by the sophists, Socrates elevates virtue to a universal meaning and proposes a rational theory of moral education, and there is a great tension between the two theories. In today's moral education, the best way to achieve the best results in moral education is to look at and apply theories dialectically without being partial to one or the other.
Downloads
References
Plato, & Wang Xiaozhao (Ed).The complete works of Plato.4.Beijing: People's Publishing House, 2017:312b, 80e, 98e, 334a.
KONG Lingxin. It is Possible to Learn virtue ? on Plato's Meno. Journal of Education,2022,(04),26-36. doi:10.14082/ j.cnki. 1673-1298.2022.04.003.
Zhang Jizhou, & Huang Shuguang. Can Virtue be Taught--On the Virtue Enlightenment of Socrates. Educational Research, 2013, (04),76-81.
Yu Youhui. Is Virtue Teachable? -- The Paradox of Virtue Education in Socrates' Philosophical Propositions. Morality and Civilization,2008, (03):62-65.
Wu Yuanfa. On the Two Ways of Western Classical Moral Education--the Comparsion of Protagoras, Meno, and Nicomachean Ethics. Modern Education Series,2014, (05):9-16.
PAN Xiaochun. What is Good Teaching: Analyzing the Concept of Teaching Ethics Based on the Herbart's Concept of Educational Teaching. Educational Theory and Practice, 2015,35 (13):50-54.
Chen Guisheng. My Point on " Virtue Can be Taught? ". Journal of Educational Science of Hunan Normal University, 2003, (03),3-5+36.
Cao Huanrong. Epicurean "medicine" for the healing of the soul: a commentary on the translation of the Diogenes Inscription of Oinouanda. Beijing: China Social Science Publishing House, 2010:16.
Aristotle & Roger Crisp (Ed). Nicomachean Ethics (2nd ed.), 2014, Cambridge University Press: preface.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Journal of Education and Educational Research
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.