Land custom and the development of adverse possession in HKSAR: Taking the case of "Adverse possession" at A Kung Ngan Village Road, Shau Kei Wan as an example

Han Shen

doi:10.54097/xwshsb05

Authors

Han Shen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/xwshsb05

Keywords:

land custom, adverse possession, land laws, land administration, Hong Kong.

Abstract

Land laws vary across regions due to geographical and cultural differences. This paper examines the evolution of land laws in common law and civil law nations, focusing on Hong Kong's transition from British common law to Chinese civil law post-1997. Despite Hong Kong's historical adherence to British legal traditions, the adoption of the Basic Law signifies a pivotal shift in legal authority. Utilizing qualitative analysis and case studies, including the landmark LEE BING CHEUNG case, this study explores Hong Kong's unique land administration model. Adverse possession, inherited from English common law, remains pivotal in land disputes but faces challenges under evolving legal frameworks. Concerns arise regarding the future of land administration in Hong Kong under Chinese governance post-2047. As Hong Kong integrates with the mainland legal system, the dynamics of land laws, including adverse possession, are subject to ongoing examination.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Scott, Ian, "Administering the New Towns of Hong Kong". Asian Survey. 22 (7): 663–4. 1982

Dixon, Martin. "Adverse possession in three jurisdictions." (2006).

Brown, Carol Necole, and Serena M. Williams. "Rethinking adverse possession: An essay on ownership and possession." Syracuse L. Rev. 60 (2009): 583.

Ching, S., & Fu, Y. "Contestability of the urban land market: an event study of Hong Kong land auctions." Regional Science and Urban Economics 33.6 (2003): 695-720.

Holdsworth, William Searle. An historical introduction to the land law. London：The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd., 2002.

Hong Chang, X. A History of English Land Law: A General Study in the Light of Seisin. 1st ed. Beijing: Peking University Press, 2009.

Crabtree, Harry. "Does Hong Kong Need a Law of Adverse Possession?" Exeter L. Rev. 46 (2021): 25.

Chen, L., & Gordon, S. B. "Whither Adverse Possession in Hong Kong? A Comparative and Statistical Study." Conveyancer and Property Lawyer 5 (2014): 413-429.

Lee, Alice. "An unsolved problem for adverse possessors of New Territories land." Hong Kong LJ 26 (1996): 7.

Katz, Larissa. "The moral paradox of adverse possession: sovereignty and revolution in property law." McGill Law Journal 55.1 (2010): 47-80.

Crabtree, Harry. "Does Hong Kong Need a Law of Adverse Possession ?" Exeter L. Rev. 46 (2021): 25.

Chen, L., & Gordon, S. B. "Whither Adverse Possession in Hong Kong? A Comparative and Statistical Study." Conveyancer and Property Lawyer 5 (2014): 413-429.

Baker, John Hamilton. An introduction to English legal history. Oxford University Press, 2019.

Holdsworth, William Searle. An historical introduction to the land law. The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd., 2002.

Merrill, Thomas W., and Henry E. Smith. Property: principles and policies. Foundation Press, 2017.

Merrill, Thomas W. "Property rules liability rules and adverse possession." Nw. UL Rev. 79 (1984): 1122.

Tay, Alice ES. "The concept of possession in the common law: Foundations for a new approach." Melb. UL Rev. 4 (1963): 476.

Hongjun, G, and Handa, C. The Original Principles of Anglo-American Law (Volumes I and II). Beijing Book Co. Inc., 2021.

Campbell, Nicholas J. "Principles of mineral ownership in the civil law and common law systems." Proceedings (American Bar Association. Section of International and Comparative Law) (1956)

Brudner, Alan. "The Unity of Property Law." Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence 4.1 (1991)

Løvschal, Mette. "The logics of enclosure: deep‐time trajectories in the spread of land tenure boundaries in late prehistoric northern Europe." Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 26.2 (2020)

Hudson, John. Land, Law, and Lordship in Anglo-Norman England. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994.

Tichelar, Michael. The Failure of Land Reform in Twentieth-Century England: The Triumph of Private Property. Routledge, 2018

Shaoqiang, Z. Governing the New Territories: Land Rights, Paternal Power, and Sovereignty. Chung Hwa Book Co. (Hong Kong) Ltd., 2016.

Bangyan F. A Hundred Years of Hong Kong Real Estate Industry. Joint Publishing (Hong Kong) Co., Ltd., 2001.

Bright, Susan, and B. E. N. McFARLANE. "Proprietary estoppel and property rights." The Cambridge Law Journal 64.2 (2005): 449-480.

Hoppe, Hans-Hermann. Democracy-the God that failed: the economics and politics of monarchy, democracy, and natural order. Transaction Publishers, 2001.

Jinglin X, and Yiqun Y. "Legal Adjustment of Hong Kong's Land Use System—Also on the Prospects After 97". Journal of Shanghai University: Social Sciences Edition 6 (1996): 82-88.

Chen, Albert HY. "The interpretation of the basic law-common law and Mainland Chinese perspectives." Hong Kong LJ 30 (2000): 380.

Lai, Lawrence Wai-chung. "The leasehold system as a means of planning by contract: the case of Hong Kong." The Town planning review (1998): 249-275.

Gray, Kevin J., and Susan Francis Gray. Elements of land law. Vol. 56. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009

Feng, L. "Hong Kong After 2047: 'One Country, Two Systems' or 'One Country, One System'?" Journal of Shenzhen University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition) 34.1 (2017): 37-43.