Operational Mechanisms and Experiences of Community Governance in Developed Countries from the Perspective of Participatory Governance: An Analysis Based on the CLEAR Model
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54097/fn6wpc46Keywords:
Participatory Governance, CLEAR Model, Community Governance, International ExperienceAbstract
Participatory governance is a key model for achieving effective governance in modern communities within social governance frameworks. Exploring effective community participatory governance is not only essential for safeguarding the rights and interests of residents but also a crucial step toward building a modernized governance system. However, in practice, many communities have not fully implemented participatory governance. To address this gap, this study examines the community governance practices of developed neighboring countries such as Japan, South Korea, and Singapore, bringing their experiences into the context of participatory governance. Using the Stokes CLEAR model, the study organizes five dimensions of governance: Can To, Like To, Enable To, Ask To, and Responded To. These dimensions offer a framework for encouraging community residents in China to engage in participatory governance. This analysis provides a model and practical reference for promoting effective resident participation in community governance, fostering an interactive process of government leadership and citizen involvement.
Downloads
References
[1] Xi Jinping. Holding high the great banner of socialism with Chinese characteristics and unitedly striving for building a modern socialist country in all aspects - Report of the 20th Party Congress, Xinhua, 2024-04-01. https://www.gov. cn/xinwen/ 2022-10/25/ content_5721685.htm.
[2] Communiqué of the Fourth Plenary Session of the 19th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. Communist Party of China. https://www.12371. cn/2019/ 10/31/ ARTI1 57251 5554956816.shtml.
[3] Tan Xiaoyan. Community-based Participatory Governance: Urban Grassroots Governance Innovation under the Perspective of Institutionalism New Horizons, 2020,(03):80-87:81; Chen Yuyong, Xu Xun. Participatory governance: a feasible path of social management innovation--a study based on the experience of community management and service innovation in Hangzhou. Zhejiang Social Science, 2013,(02): 62- 72+158:62.
[4] Zhuo Wenhao. Research on the Role Mechanism of Community Participatory Governance in Sharing Perspective. Supervisor: Cao Xianqiang. Shandong University, 2024:3.
[5] Chen Jichang,Jiang Wen. A Study on Government Participation in Community Building in South Korea and Its Implications. Journal of Yanbian University (Social Science Edition),2023,56(02): 5-12+1:7.
[6] WEI Hanbin,TANG Yan,JIN Shiyong. Community building in Korea based on government guidance and government-citizen cooperation. Planner, 2015, 31(05): 145-150:147.
[7] Luo Zhuomao,Zheng Ming,Pan Mengfei,et al. Research on community construction and community governance model in Japan. Zhejiang Architecture, 2022, 39(02):72-75:74.
[8] Cao Kejing,Wu Songtao,Lv Fei. Japan's community building experience and its inspiration for public participation in China. Low Temperature Building Technology, 2022 ,44(01): 28-32+39:29.
[9] E. S. Chia, "Singapore's smart nation program - Enablers and challenges," 2016 11th System of Systems Engineering Conference (SoSE), Kongsberg, Norway, 2016, 1-5.
[10] Li Hao-Yu,Yao Zhi-Hao. The development evolution of community building and the inspiration for community renewal in China[C]// China Society of Urban Planning. People's City, Planning Empowerment - Proceedings of the 2022 China Urban Planning Annual Conference (02 Urban Renewal). [Publisher unknown],2023:9.
[11] Jean-Jacques Rousseau. The Social Contract. He Zhaowu, Translation. Beijing: Commercial Press, 1980:52.
[12] Karl Kohn. On Democracy. Nie Chongxin, Zhu Xiuxian, Translation. Beijing: Commercial Press,2007:19.
[13] Carol Peterman. Participation and Democratic Theory. Chen Yao, Translation. Shanghai: Shanghai People's Publishing House, 2006:22.
[14] Vincent Ostrom,et al. Local Government in the United States, translated by Jing Min and Chen Youhong. Beijing:Peking University Press,2004.
[15] Gerry Stock,You Xiangbin. New Localism, Participation and Networked Community Governance. Journal of National School of Administration, 2006, (03): 92-95:94.
[16] NonProfit Organization, https://www.npo-homepage. go.jp/ about/npo-kisochishiki/nposeido-gaiyou.
[17] Zheng Nan. The Development of Grassroots Organizations and Regional Social Construction in Northeast China--Taking Japan's "New Publicity Theory" as a Reference. Learning and Exploration, 2015, (09): 30-34:34.
[18] Taka Akio. Reconsidering the "Concept of Neighborhood Association" - Using the "Basic Bill on Community Activities" (tentative title) as material. Yamanashi Gakuin University "Proceedings of Law", 2009.
[19] Li Baogeng, Zhan Guobin. Exploration of the role of non-profit organizations in rural social governance. Modern Business,2014, (18):268-269:268.
[20] Japan Cabinet Office NPO website. https://www.npo-homepage.go.jp/.
[21] Gao Hong,Wang Xiang. Empowering Social Organizations: The Practical Logic and Experience of Community Building in Japan. Changbai Journal, 2023, (03): 121-130:126-127.
[22] Hidaka, Akio. Basic Municipalities and Neighborhood Association Neighborhood Associations. Shunposha, 2018,17-18.
[23] Tokyo Metropolitan Meguro Ward Government Settlement Residents' Association. https://www.city. meguro. tokyo. jp/ chiikishinkou/kurashi/community/kaigi.html.
[24] Seoul City Official Website|Details of Community Community Support Program. https://chinese. seoul.go. kr/ Policy Information / Core policy / Main business /2- Community community /.
[25] Shin, Sun-hwa. Research on Community Building Resident Subjects and Community Activities. Doctoral Dissertation, Kyungsung University,2017,108.
[26] Hae-sook Seo. The living use and living way of folk culture in community building. Nandao Cultural Research, 2014, (27): 237-265.
[27] Gwangju Tourism, Korea|Yanglim-dong Penguin Village Craft Street. https://tour.gwangju.go.kr/ chn/tour/info/village/002. cs?act=view&infoId=1287&category=002&searchCondition= &searchKeyword=&pageIndex=1.
[28] Chen Jichang,Jiang Wen. A Study on Government Participation in Community Building in South Korea and Its Implications. Journal of Yanbian University (Social Science Edition),2023,56(02):5-12+141:9-10.
[29] Wang Chenghui. Discussion on the path of institutionalization of community planning--Based on the comparison of New York of the United States, Seoul of South Korea and Singapore. Planner,2020,36(20):84-89:86.
[30] Xu Lin. Building “future communities”: the logic and mechanism of governance in Singapore. China Social Science Journal, 2020-3-12, https://www.cssn.cn/skgz/ bwyc/ 202208/ t20220803_5456751.shtml.
[31] RSVP (Retired and Senior Volunteer Programme). https:// rsvp. org.sg/.
[32] BYTE.sg: Technology Empowerment for Better Life. https://www.imda.gov.sg/digitalforlife/stories-listing/bytesg---technology- empowerment-for-better-life.
[33] Wei Wei,Paths and Characteristics of Social Governance Modernization in Singapore. China Social Science Journal, 2022-08-15, https://www.cssn.cn/skgz/ bwyc/202208/ t2022 0822_ 5480343.shtml.
[34] Singapore People's Association Network. https://www.pa. gov.sg/about-us/about-pa/.
[35] PARK Sung-yin, JANG Lee, LEE In-hee. Old Village Renovation and Community Reconstruction in Korean Cities: The Case of Noksan-dong, Changwon City. Shanghai Urban Planning, 2018, (01):72-76:74.
[36] Centre for Liveable Cities, Singapore and the Seoul Institute. Planning for Communities: Lessons from Seoul and Singapore. Singapore: CLC Publications. 2017:36-37.
[37] Wang Chenghui. Exploration on the path of institutionalization of community planning--Based on the comparison of New York of the United States, Seoul of South Korea and Singapore. Planner, 2020, 36(20):84-89:86.
[38] YANG Changyu, YAO Zigang,FANG Tianhong. Research on Community Governance System with Multi-party Collaboration--Revelation of Singapore Model[C]//Chinese Society of Urban Planning, Chengdu Municipal People's Government. Spatial Governance for High-Quality Development - Proceedings of the Annual Conference on Urban Planning in China 2021 (19 Housing and Community Planning). East China University of Science and Technology, 2021:8.
[39] Singapore People's Association Network. https://www. pa.gov.sg/.
[40] Tsang, C.M.. Strong government, strong society: Singapore and U.S. experiences in modernizing social governance. Social Governance, 2016, (06): 141-152: 146.
[41] Zhai Huijie. Experiences of Community Governance in Europe and America. Social Governance, 2023,(04): 74-83: 80
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Academic Journal of Management and Social Sciences

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

