On the Educational Significance of Historical Textbooks for Adolescents' Ideological Consciousness, and Their Impact on Sino-Japanese Relations — Taking the Changes in Narrations on the War of Resistance against Japan in Chinese and Japanese History Textbooks as an Example

Authors

  • Zhiai Liu

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/7swrhs69

Keywords:

Chinese and Japanese History Textbooks, Revisions, Adolescents, Ideological Consciousness, Sino-Japanese Relations.

Abstract

Significant disparities exist in the narratives of the Sino-Japanese War (1931-1945) as presented in Chinese and Japanese history textbooks. Both countries, influenced by their unique political, economic, and cultural stances, have made diverse revisions to their history textbooks at different times. This paper compares narrative changes in the history textbooks of both countries, contending that textbook revisions aim to shape adolescents' ideological consciousness and historical perspectives, influencing their political socialization tendencies and behaviors. As Japan refashions its historical textbooks, it impedes the young generation's ability to glean insights from history, potentially cultivating a cohort characterized by unwarranted arrogance yet lacking a sense of responsibility. The ongoing discourse surrounding historical textbooks consistently rekindles poignant memories among the Chinese populace, instilling fears of Japan repeating the errors of militarism and consequently, fortifying the younger generation's recollection of a humiliating past. China and Japan, not only wielding significant influence on regional security in East Asia but also playing pivotal roles in global peace and stability, should embrace equitable and amicable exchanges. Such exchanges can foster increased mutual trust and reciprocal benefits, representing the appropriate path for China and Japan, nations separated by a narrow body of water with a longstanding history of friendship.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Michael W·Apple, L. Christian Smith (Eds.): "Textbook Politics", Shanghai: East China Normal University Press, 2005, 4.

Lan Shun-De: "Textbook Ideology: A Historical Review and Empirical Analysis", Taipei: Wu-Nan Book Inc., 2nd Edition, 2010.

Wu Guangyi: "Evaluation of the Description of the War of Aggression Against China in Japanese Middle School History Textbooks." Japanese Studies. 2003, 03: 47-62.

Wang Duyu: "Study on the Exposition of Japan's Aggression Against China in Junior High School History Textbooks Since the Establishment of New China." Shandong Normal University. 2018.

Liu Chang: "Research on the Image of Japan in History Textbooks". Suzhou University. 2022.

Zhao Yumeng: "Sino-Korean History Education and Relations with Japan". Jilin University. 2018.

Huang Yiqi: "The Concealment of Ideological Indoctrination". Nanjing University, 2021. p.16.

Yi Nanhe: "Remembering and Forgetting War: Myth Creation by the Elites, Public Response, and Sino-Japanese Relations" 1950-2006, History and Memory, 2007, (19) 2: 43-74.

Zhao Changlin: "On the Ideological Function of Textbooks [J]". Journal of Liaocheng University (Social Sciences Edition), 2016, (04): 116-121.

Lee Hee-Yu: "Northeast Asian Historical Issues and Issues of Peace and Cooperation [J]". Contemporary Korea, 2006, (03): 6-10.

Ren Xiaoxia: "Empirical Research on the Political Socialization of College Students – A Survey of 600 Undergraduates at Huazhong University of Science and Technology", Master's Thesis, 2006.

Yuan Songxi: "Political Socialization: Theory and Evidence", Taipei: San Min Book Co., Ltd., 2004.

Downloads

Published

28-05-2024

How to Cite

Liu, Z. . (2024). On the Educational Significance of Historical Textbooks for Adolescents’ Ideological Consciousness, and Their Impact on Sino-Japanese Relations — Taking the Changes in Narrations on the War of Resistance against Japan in Chinese and Japanese History Textbooks as an Example. Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences, 32, 47-53. https://doi.org/10.54097/7swrhs69