Meta-analysis of the Impact of Narrative Care on the Quality of Life of Critically Ill Patients

Quanliang Wang; Yinyan He; Fanlei Bu; Xianjing Shang; Shijing Yang; Yu Li

doi:10.54097/r6ctw478

Authors

Quanliang Wang
Yinyan He
Fanlei Bu
Xianjing Shang
Shijing Yang
Yu Li

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/r6ctw478

Keywords:

Narrative Nursing, Seriously Patients, Mental State, Quality of Life, Meta-analysis

Abstract

Objective To systematically evaluate the effect of narrative care on the quality of life of critically ill patients. Methods Computer searches of PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, ProQuest, Wiley, CNKI, Wanfang database for randomized controlled trials on the effects of narrative care on the psychological and quality of life of seriously patients were conducted, and the search time frame was from database creation to December 2022. The literature was screened, extracted, and evaluated for methodological quality by two investigators according to inclusion and exclusion criteria. The quality of the literature was evaluated using the Jadad scale, and the risk of bias was assessed by the recommended criteria in the Cochrane 5.1.0 manual. The data were extracted from the literature that met the inclusion criteria after screening. Meta-analysis was performed using RevMan 5.4. Results The final literature included 32 articles with 3073 patients. Meta-analysis results showed that narrative care was effective in improving patients' quality of life, including physical and psychological dimensions, compared with conventional care. Conclusions Narrative care helps to improve the psychological status and quality of life of seriously patients, with important implications for both physical and psychological dimensions.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

WEI Xiu-xia, ZHANG Xiu-wei, PENG Jian-ying, ZHONG Yi-yu. Current status of research on post-ICU syndrome in foreign countries[J]. Chinese Journal of Nursing,2016,51(01):84-89.

He Manman, Jiang Zhixia, Zhang Fang, Li Xiaojuan, Hu Rujun. Analysis of potential categories of symptom characteristics in patients with post-ICU syndrome[J]. Chinese Journal of Nursing,2021,56(10):1445-1452.

ZHANG Xiying, JIANG Zhixia, LIU Qilan, HE Manman, ZHANG Fang, XIANG Qianling, HU Rujun. Analysis of potential categories and influencing factors of fatigue trajectory in patients with post-ICU syndrome[J]. Chinese Journal of Nursing,2022,57(03):272-278.

Artioli Giovanna,Foà Chiara,Taffurelli Chiara. An integrated narrative nursing model: towards a new healthcare paradigm. [J]. Acta bio-medica: Atenei Parmensis,2016,87(4 - S).

Yang Yan, Jiang Anli. Current status of domestic and international research on narrative nursing clinical practice[J]. Chinese Journal of Practical Nursing, 2017, 33(24): 1917-1920. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1672-7088.2017.24.019.

Liu XF, Kang FY, Li ZS, Guo MM, Yang YJ. The effect of narrative nursing in patients with breast cancer during chemotherapy [J]. Nursing Research,2021,35(19):3556-3560.

Higgins JPT,Thomas J,Chandler J,et al. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions[M]. 2nd ed. Chichester (UK):John Wiley & Sons,2019.

Ware JE,Sherbourne CD. The MOS 36-Item short-form health surve(SF-36). Conceptual framework and item selection[J]. Med Care,1992,30(6):473-483.

EuroQol Group. EuroQol— a new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life [J]. Health Policy,1990, 16(3): 199-208. DOI:10.1016/0168-8510 (90) 90421-9.

Jadad AR,Moor RA,Carroll D,et al. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials' blinding necessary[J]. Control Clin Trials,1996,17(1):1-12.DOI:10.1016/0197-2456 (95)00134-4.

Eddie Cheng, Jun Chen, Fang Wang, Lingling Wu. Impact of narrative nursing on young and middle-aged AMI patients after percutaneous coronary stenting[J]. Qilu Nursing Journal, 2021, 27 (05):66-68.

HAN Jing, HAN Xue, XIA Chengjun. Application effect of narrative nursing on perioperative cervical cancer patients[J]. Psychology Monthly,2022,17(02):128-129+137.DOI:10. 197 38/ j. cnki. psy.2022.02.042.

Hu Y. Effect of narrative nursing on recovery after PCI for acute myocardial infarction in young people[J]. China Urban and Rural Enterprise Health,2022,37(12):112-114.DOI:10. 16286/j. 1003-5052.2022.12.041.

Shakeri J, Ahmadi SM, Maleki F, Hesami MR, Parsa Moghadam A, Ahmadzade A, Shirzadi M, Elahi A. Effectiveness of Group Narrative Therapy on Depression, Quality of Life, and Anxiety in People with Amphetamine Addiction: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Iran J Med Sci. 2020 Mar; 45 (2):91-99. doi: 10.30476/IJMS.2019.45829. PMID: 32210485; PMCID: PMC7071554.

JIANG Chun, ZHANG Lingyan, LAN Xueying. Effects of five-step narrative nursing on anxiety, depression and quality of life of children with SLE[J]. Qilu Nursing Journal, 2020, 26 (21):108-110.

JIANG Manzhen, YANG Chaoxia. Effects of narrative therapy on elderly maintenance hemodialysis patients[J]. Psychology Monthly,2022,17(03): 187-189.DOI:10.19738/ j.cnki.psy. 2022. 03.063.

Jiang XJ. The effect of narrative nursing on the psychological state and survival quality of advanced cancer patients[J]. Clinical Research,2021,29(02):154-156.

Jiang X-P. Effects of narrative care on negative emotions and quality of life of hospital-acquired acute kidney injury patients[J]. China Medical Innovation,2018,15(23):74-78.

JIANG Yuehua, CHEN Lihuan, HAN Fuxin. Effect of narrative nursing intervention on negative psychology and quality of life of advanced gastric cancer patients[J]. Contemporary Nurses (Lower Decade),2019,26(02):145-147.

Li D, Li WJ, Cheng LB. Effects of narrative therapy on pain stress, psychological resilience and quality of life in lung cancer patients[J]. Cancer Progress,2021,19(23):2471-2475.

Liu L. Effect of narrative nursing on psychological state and physiological stress response of patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting[J]. Chinese and Foreign Medicine, 2022,41 (13):173-177.DOI:10.16662/j.cnki.1674-0742.2022. 13. 173.

Li L, Liu SH, Wang J. Analysis of the application effect of evidence-based nursing combined with narrative nursing on gynecological malignant tumor surgery patients[J]. Chinese Community Physician,2022,38(33):103-105.

Li Na. The effect of narrative nursing on the psychology and quality of life of young patients with acute myocardial infarction[J]. Narrative Medicine,2022,5(02):88-93.

LU Xin, WU Weili, WU Li, LI Min, SHI Mengyu, ZHAO Yujie. A study on the effect of narrative nursing on the sense of shame in elderly patients with cerebral infarction[J]. China Rural Health,2021,13(13):24-25+27.

Luo Xiaomei, Zhong Chunhong, Cao Dan. Application of narrative nursing in patients with cancer fatalism at the early stage of nasopharyngeal carcinoma radiotherapy[J]. Qilu Nursing Journal,2022,28(24):4-6.

Li XP, Ding SL, Xu LL. The effect of narrative nursing model in ovarian cancer patients[J]. International Journal of Nursing,2019(15):2333-2336.

Liu Yanjun, Mo Haidi, Liang Xiumei. Effects of narrative nursing on patients with gastric ulcer with perforation[J]. Chinese and Foreign Medical Research,2022,20(19):98-101. DOI:10.14033/j.cnki.cfmr.2022.19.025.

Liu Y. Application of narrative nursing in elderly patients with cerebral infarction[J]. Chinese and Foreign Medical Research, 2022, 20(08):97-100.DOI:10.14033/j.cnki.cfmr.2022.08.027.

Ma L, Bian LL, Zhai QH. Effects of narrative nursing on negative emotions and quality of life of patients with advanced cancer[J]. Practical Chinese and Western Medicine Clinic,2018, 18(09):175-177.DOI:10.13638/j.issn.1671-4040.2018.09.087.

SHAO Huidi, ZHONG Xiaohua, SHEN Aijuan, LUO Xueping, JIN Yiming. Effects of narrative care on psychological status and quality of life of elderly patients with chronic diseases[J]. Chinese Family Medicine,2021,19(09):1600-1603.DOI: 10. 16766 / j.cnki.issn.1674-4152.002121.

Huaqiong Shi, Jing Liu. Effects of periprocedural care for radical nephrectomy for kidney cancer on patients' prognosis, social support and psychological status based on narrative medicine model[J]. International Journal of Nursing,2021, 40(21): 3962-3965.

Shi Zufen, Tong Hui, Wang Lisheng. Effects of narrative care on negative emotions and quality of life of maintenance hemodialysis patients[J]. China Clinical Nursing,2022,14 (10): 621-624+628.

Wang D. Effects of narrative therapy on depressed mood, quality of life and social functioning in patients after PCI for acute myocardial infarction[J]. China Practical Medicine, 2019, 14 (26):126-128.DOI:10.14163/j.cnki.11-5547/r.2019. 26. 071.

Wang QM. Effects of narrative nursing combined with stress relief on psychological resilience, health beliefs and survival quality of lung cancer immunotherapy patients[J]. Contemporary Nurses (Zhong Lun),2022,29(09):82-85.DOI: 10. 19792/j.cnki.1006-6411.2022.26.026.

Wang Y, Zheng Y, Cui LP. Application of narrative psychological care combined with online group cognitive-behavioral therapy in patients undergoing intradural tumor resection [J]. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing,2021, 27(36): 5008-5012.

WU Yingying, WU Xia. Effects of narrative therapy on postoperative pain, negative emotions and quality of life in patients with osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures[J]. Chinese Journal of Health Psychology,2021,29(10):1515-1519. DOI:10.13342/j.cnki.cjhp.2021.10.016.

Xia J, Wang X. Observation on the effect of clinical application of modified narrative nursing model on improving negative emotions and quality of life of liver failure patients[J]. General Practice Nursing,2021,19(28):3963-3965.

ZHAO Jing, MOU Xuhong, JIN Yi, GU Lili, QIU Ju, LU Jinghua. Effects of narrative care on negative emotions and quality of life of patients with difficult-to-heal wounds[J]. Evidence-Based Nursing,2021,7(16):2250-2253.

ZHANG Lili, FU Te, XU Xu, LI Weiwei, ZHANG Juan, WANG Rui, WANG Xinmei, FANG Huiqiong, ZENG Wenli. Evaluation of the effectiveness of narrative nursing in the implementation of protective medicine for elderly cancer patients[J]. Nursing Research,2021,35(23):4298-4301.

Zhang Shan, Chen Bohong. Effects of narrative nursing combined with online cognitive behavioral intervention on postoperative psychological status and quality of life of cervical cancer patients[J]. Clinical Medical Engineering,2022, 29(11):1569-1570.

ZHAO Suhua, CHANG Shuying, KANG Yanxia. Research on the effects of narrative therapy on postoperative depressed mood, quality of life and social functioning in patients with eye removal[J]. General Practice Nursing,2018,16(35):4359-4362.

Zhou ZY. The effect of narrative therapy on the quality of life of patients with somatoform disorders[J]. Nursing Research, 2012, 26(10):909-910.

HUANG Hui, LIU Yilan. Research progress on the clinical application of narrative nursing[J]. Chinese Journal of Nursing, 2016,51(02):196-200.

ZHANG Xiaoyi, HE Hong, WU Aijuan. Effects of narrative medical education model on foot knowledge level and metabolic indexes of middle- and high-risk diabetic foot patients[J]. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing,2016, 22(05): 639-643.