Constructing Exceptions to the Principle of Independence in Electronic Letters of Credit

Authors

  • Xinyu Xu

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/9rvfae74

Keywords:

Electronic letter of credit, principle of Independence, exception construction, technical malfunction, invalid electronic record.

Abstract

The rise of electronic letters of credit has enhanced efficiency while challenging the traditional principle of independence due to issues like technical failures and the legitimacy of electronic records. This paper innovatively transcends the conventional "fraud exception" framework by systematically establishing two novel exception rules. First, it introduces the "Serious Technical Malfunction Exception," defining its elements as the severity, persistence, and transactional obstruction of the malfunction, coupled with the absence of gross negligence by the bank. It argues that in such cases, relief should be extended through deferred performance rather than absolute refusal of payment. Second, it establishes the "Manifestly Invalid Electronic Record Exception," emphasizing that when an electronic record is inherently invalid due to formal or substantive defects, the bank retains the right to refuse payment within the scope of its prima facie examination. To realize this institutional framework, this paper proposes specific pathways to refine the eUCP 2.0 rules: introducing a deferral mechanism for technical failures, refining standards for electronic record validity, and restructuring bank exemption clauses to shift risk allocation from "unilateral transfer" to "fair sharing." This research offers a solution for the electronic letter of credit rule system that combines theoretical innovation with practical value, effectively balancing the goals of efficiency and fairness in letter of credit transactions in the digital age.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Zhang M. Q. and Li W. P. Re-examining the Principle of Surface Conformity in Bank Document Examination under Documentary Letters of Credit. Investment Research, 2010, (3): 59–63.

[2] Cheng J. Discussion on the Application of EDI Technology in Documentary Letters of Credit. International Finance Research, 1995, (4): 55–58.

[3] Lu L. Criteria for Determining Letter of Credit Fraud and Bases for Issuing Stop Payment Orders: A Comparative Study from Chinese, British, and American Legal Perspectives. Jianghai Academic Journal, 2014, (3): 216–220, 239.

[4] Kozolchyk Boris. The digitalization of international trade instruments (diti) and its contribution to economic development and employment in developing and developed nations. International In-House Counsel Journal, 2023, 16 (64): 8601-8632.

[5] Lu L. Big Data Empowerment: Legal Responses to the Letter of Credit Crisis—With Commentary on the ICC Electronic Letter of Credit Series Rules. Journal of Southeast University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2019, 21 (6): 85–93, 147.

[6] Xing A. F. and Fu S. J. Research on China's Electronic Signature Legislation and Practice Issues. Science and Technology & Law (Chinese and English), 2022, (3): 14–23.

[7] Mansfield Cathy Lesser. It takes thief.. and bank: protecting consumers from fraud and scams on p2p payment platforms. University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 2024, 57 (2): 351-416.

[8] Lubisi Tivoneleni Edmund, Jegede Ademola Oluborode, and Letuka Puleng. International human rights law and the access of children of asylum seekers to social assistance in South Africa. Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa, 2020, 53 (3): 1-32.

[9] Wang J. G. The Unidirectionality of the Principle of Independence in Letters of Credit. China Foreign Exchange, 2023, (8): 52–54.

[10] Jiang A. L. and Wang J. J. Legislative Improvements Against Letter of Credit Fraud in China Under UCP600 Rules. Journal of Shandong University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2012, (6): 35–40.

[11] Ji T. T. Legal Issues in Electronic Letters of Credit (Master's Thesis). East China University of Political Science and Law, 2020.

[12] Liu Z. Z. Legal Issues Concerning the Security of Electronic Letters of Credit in International Trade (Master's Thesis). Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 2015.

[13] Gu S. H. Research on the Electronic Operation and Risk Issues of Letters of Credit in the Internet Era. Economic Research Reference, 2017, (64): 43–46.

[14] Ouyang R. H. and Li L. K. The Mechanism and Pathways of Blockchain Technology in Promoting Trade Innovation and Development. International Trade, 2022, (2): 47–57.

[15] Aminizadeh Laya. Enhancing the efficiency of international trade: exploring the impact of blockchain technology on letters of credit within existing legal frameworks. Debreceni Jogi Muhely Legal Workshop of Debrecen, 2023, 2023 (3-4): 5-25.

Downloads

Published

16-04-2026

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Xu, X. (2026). Constructing Exceptions to the Principle of Independence in Electronic Letters of Credit. Journal of Education and Educational Research, 18(1), 170-176. https://doi.org/10.54097/9rvfae74