The Portrayal of Individual Predicaments in an Era of Transition: A Cross-Cultural Comparison of the "Superfluous Man" Images of Ashley and Gao Juexin
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54097/19an2g41Keywords:
Ashley; Gao Juexin; Disciplinary Power.Abstract
This paper focuses on the predicaments of individuals in the transformative era and conducts a cross-cultural comparison of two "superfluous people" characters, Ashley from Gone with the Wind and Gao Juexin from Family. It clarifies the core characteristics of "superfluous people" in Russian literature, including spiritual contradictions, lack of practical ability and estrangement from their times, and verifies that the concept applies to both Western and Chinese literary works. Ashley clung to tradition as the Southern American plantation civilization declined, while Gao Juexin suppressed himself amid the collapse of China’s feudal family system; both drifted apart from their eras and embodied "superfluity" in their own ways. Their cultural roots differ as Ashley’s predicament stemmed from the rift between his ideal of the old Southern aristocracy and the harsh post-war reality, leaving him unable to find a foothold in the new era, while Gao Juexin’s dilemma arose as filial piety and fraternal responsibility in Chinese family ethics eroded his sense of self. Drawing on Foucault’s theory of power discourse, the paper explores how the cultural power system "disciplines" these two characters, and through the "superfluous people" images, Gone with the Wind mourns the Southern civilization while Family criticizes the feudal system.
Downloads
References
[1] Li X. Gao Juexin, the “superfluous man” in Ba Jin’s works. Jiaying Literature, 2024, 19: 66–68.
[2] Cheng J. Turgenev and Russian Populism. East China Normal University, 2019.
[3] Zhang X. Solitary Men of the Time—Analysis of the Images of “Superfluous Man”, “Surplus Zero”, and “Outsider”. Tianjin Normal University, 2014.
[4] Xiao Y. Family and individual in an era of change: An interpretation of Gone with the Wind. Xuehai, 2021, 01: 32–53.
[5] Qi M. Three faces of the “cowardly intellectual” in modern Chinese literature. Modern Chinese Literature Studies, 2018, 09: 33–41.
[6] Zhu Y. Gone with the Wind: A literary mirror of the difficult transformation of agrarianism in the American South. Social Sciences Research, 2016, 03: 186–192.
[7] Qiao Y., Lin D. The evolution of time-space consciousness and the birth of the “new youth”—A re-reading of Ba Jin’s Family. Qiushi Journal, 2020, 47(06): 155–162.
[8] Xu M. Contradictions and the tragedy of the times—Taking Gao Juexin in Ba Jin’s Family as an example. Industrial and Science Tribune, 2022, 21(15): 79–80.
[9] Yang L. “Confession of life”: Ba Jin and Family. Modern Chinese Literature Studies, 2023, 03: 1–15.
[10] Hu Y. Body, power-discourse and history: Foucault’s ideological criticism. Foreign Theoretical Trends, 2021, 05: 82–91.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Journal of Education and Educational Research

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.









