Categorical Identification of Criminal Liability for Semi-Autonomous Vehicles

Authors

  • Yihan Zhang

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/jredp386

Keywords:

Autonomous Driving, Criminal Liability, Duty of Care, Duty of Takeover, Exemption from Criminal Liability.

Abstract

The widespread adoption of conditionally autonomous vehicles has rendered it imperative for China to regulate them within the criminal law framework. Confronted with challenges including the determination of criminal liability subjects, the assessment of subjective fault, and the delineation of causal relationships, the traditional model for identifying criminal liability in conventional vehicle cases is no longer applicable to autonomous vehicles, as autonomous driving systems cannot qualify as subjects of criminal liability. Drawing on the theory of objective imputation, the principle of reliance, and the objectives of industry development and legal regulation, this paper positively identifies the criminal liability of producers across the production and circulation stages, categorizes the duty of care for drivers into pre-driving and in-driving phases, and emphasizes the need to restrict such duties. From the perspective of criminal liability exemption, it negatively limits the scope of liability for relevant subjects by examining various potential natural or man-made exceptional circumstances. This approach achieves the dynamic transfer and multi-layered control of risks associated with conditionally autonomous vehicles between drivers and producers, ensuring the reasonable distribution of criminal liability among all stakeholders.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Zhuang Yonglian, Huang Jingping, Gao Yandong, et al. Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Criminal Rule of Law [J]. People's Procuratorate, 2018, (01): 41 - 48.

[2] Liu Xianquan. "Internal Troubles" and "External Threats" in the Age of Artificial Intelligence and Criminal Liability [J]. Oriental Law, 2018, (01): 134 - 142.

[3] Xu Ximing. A New Perspective on Criminal Liability for Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Journal of Chongqing University of Posts and Telecommunications (Social Science Edition), 2020, 32 (05): 44 - 50.

[4] Pi Yong. Basic Issues Concerning the Criminal Rule of Law for Artificial Intelligence [J]. Journal of Comparative Law, 2018, (05): 149 - 166.

[5] Zhao Sicong. On the Criminal Risks of Autonomous Driving and Their Responses [J]. Northern Legal Science, 2022, 16 (02): 132 - 142.

[6] Lin Yujia. An Analysis of Negligent Crimes in Autonomous Driving Accidents [J]. Journal of Chongqing University (Social Science Edition), 2024, 30 (06): 238 - 249.

[7] Zhou Mingchuan. On the Criminal Liability for Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Journal of Shanghai Jiao Tong University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2019, 27 (01): 36 - 43.

[8] Jiang Su. The Challenges of Autonomous Vehicles to the Law [J]. China Law Review, 2018, (02): 180 - 189.

[9] Yao Wanqin. The Theory of Objective Imputation and the Attribution of Criminal Liability for Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Driving [J]. Journal of Dalian University of Technology (Social Sciences Edition), 2023, 44 (06): 93 - 101.

[10] Huang Chenchen. The Division and Undertaking of Criminal Liability in Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Journal of Dalian Maritime University (Social Science Edition), 2021, 20 (03): 40 - 47.

[11] Cai Xian. The Takeover Duty and Its Criminal Attribution in the Human-Machine Co-Driving Model [J]. Journal of Soochow University (Law Edition), 2023, 10 (03): 27 - 40.

[12] Huang Bo. The Criminal Law Response to Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Tianfu New Discussion, 2018, (04): 112 - 118.

[13] Wang Ying. How is Law Possible? ——A Legal Perspective on Risk Scenarios of Autonomous Driving Technology[J]. Law and Social Development, 2019, 25 (06): 99 - 112.

[14] Cai Xian. The Development of the Attribution System for Negligent Crimes in Autonomous Driving[J]. Journal of Comparative Law, 2023, (04): 65 - 81.

[15] Chen Jinghui. The Legal Nature of Algorithms: Speech, Trade Secrets, or Due Process? [J]. Journal of Comparative Law, 2020, (02): 120 - 132.

[16] Long Min. The Identification and Distribution of Criminal Liability for Traffic Accidents Involving Autonomous Driving [J]. Journal of East China University of Political Science and Law, 2018, 21 (06): 77 - 82.

[17] A Jincheng. A Hierarchical Theory of Algorithm Transparency [J]. Chinese Journal of Law, 2023, 45 (02): 52 - 66.

[18] Shi Jieyang. The Demarcation of Criminal Liability Between Drivers and Producers in Human-Machine Interaction Scenarios [J]. Huxiang Forum, 2025, 38 (05): 112 - 124.

Downloads

Published

16-04-2026

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Zhang, Y. (2026). Categorical Identification of Criminal Liability for Semi-Autonomous Vehicles. Journal of Education and Educational Research, 18(1), 509-520. https://doi.org/10.54097/jredp386