Construction and Implementation of Effectiveness Evaluation for Practical Education in Universities from the Perspective of Value-Added Evaluation
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54097/jxaznn10Keywords:
Value-Added Evaluation, Practical Education, Effectiveness EvaluationAbstract
Practical education in universities is a crucial pathway for implementing the fundamental task of "fostering virtue through education" (Lide Shuren). However, current effectiveness evaluations suffer from several issues, such as prioritizing results over processes, favoring qualitative over quantitative analysis, and neglecting individual student differences. Based on the theory of Value-Added Evaluation (VAE), this paper systematically explores the application logic and practical paths for evaluating the effectiveness of practical education. First, it clarifies the connotation of VAE, emphasizing its process-oriented and developmental characteristics that focus on the "net gain" of student development. Second, it argues the necessity of introducing VAE from two dimensions: theoretical deficiency and practical demands (student-centeredness, efficiency and equity, and growth promotion). Finally, it constructs an indicator system that involves multiple evaluation subjects and aligns with the core essence of practical education, utilizing value-added models to achieve a closed-loop mechanism of "evaluation-feedback-optimization." The study indicates that VAE can effectively compensate for the shortcomings of traditional evaluation methods, dynamically present the "value-added" progress of students' practical qualities, and contribute to enhancing educational equity and the quality of practical education.
Downloads
References
[1] Cory K.,Kata M.,& Jonah E.Value-added modeling: A review [J]. Economics of Education Review, 2015(47):180-195.
[2] Sanders, W. L., & Horn, S. P. The Tennessee value-added assessment system (TVAAS): Mixed-model methodology in educational assessment. Journal of Personnel Evaluation in Education[J].Journal of Personnel Evaluation in Education, 1994, 8(03), 299-311.
[3] Chetty,R.,Friedman,J.Rockoff,R.Measuring the impacts of teachers II:Teacher value-added and student outcomes in adulthood[J]. American Economic Review,2014, 104(09), 2633-2679.
[4] Peng Shunxu, Zhang Hanyu. Theoretical reflections and practical explorations of educational value-added evaluation. Science Education Article Collects, 2021(35): 10–12.
[5] Yang Xiaowei. Understanding and applying value-added evaluation in the context of educational equity. Educational Measurement and Evaluation, 2020(08): 8–10+18.
[6] Li Xiangping, Zhou Zuoyu, Liang Xianping. Research on value-added evaluation and quality assurance in higher education: A review of theory and methods. Tsinghua Journal of Education, 2013, 34(04): 40–45.
[7] Gao Huiyan. Theoretical connotations and practical pathways of value-added evaluation for ideological and political education of college students in the new era. China Higher Education, 2023(01): 34–37.
[8] Lai Feng, Zhang Xiwen. The value and integrated innovation of value-added evaluation-based ideological and political education in universities. Jiangsu Higher Education, 2023(04): 113–119.
[9] Xiao Qingshan. Constructing an assessment and evaluation system for college students' social practice: Based on the value-added concept. Contemporary Education Practice and Teaching Research, 2018(12): 219–220.
[10] Zhang Yuguang, Lin Fengchun, Guo Changhong. Construction of an evaluation system for college students' social practice at local engineering universities — A case study of Guangdong University of Technology. China Youth Study, 2014(08): 52–55+91.
[11] Xiao Shujian. Research on an evaluation indicator system for college students' social practice based on student satisfaction. Party Construction and Ideological Education in Schools, 2015(15): 58–59.
[12] Huang Ping. Exploring the construction of an evaluation system for college students' social practice. Education and Vocation, 2008(06): 117–119.
[13] Zhang Jinhui, Liang Botong. Research on an evaluation system for the educational effectiveness of college students' social practice based on the CIPP model. Party Construction and Ideological Education in Schools, 2017(16): 56–58.
[14] Tan Chuanbao, Wu Yuefei, Gao Sirui, et al. Simply advocating social practice is far from enough — Research on the impact of ideological and political course social practice teaching models on college students' sense of gain. Tsinghua Journal of Education, 2021, 42(01): 51–56+96.
[15] Li Zilong, Wang Xiaoni, Liu Weiting. Survey research on the current status of social practice and its educational effectiveness for college students at Anhui University of Chinese Medicine. Literature and Education Materials, 2022 (04): 200–203.
[16] Wang Yue. Construction of an evaluation indicator system for holiday social practice effectiveness. Talent, 2018(08): 58+60.
[17] Liu Weiting. Research on evaluation of social practice education effectiveness in universities. Journal of Huainan Vocational and Technical College, 2021, 21(05): 56–57.
[18] Cui Yuping, Li Zhixin. Measurement and improvement pathways for the non-economic benefits of college students' social practice. Journal of Educational Studies, 2022, 18(02): 134–147.
[19] Zhang Jinhui, Liang Botong. Research on an evaluation system for the educational effectiveness of college students' social practice based on the CIPP model. Party Construction and Ideological Education in Schools, 2017(16): 56–58.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Journal of Education and Educational Research

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.









